Index | Thread | Search

From:
Mark Kettenis <mark.kettenis@xs4all.nl>
Subject:
Re: bgpd: drop authors from RFC list
To:
Claudio Jeker <cjeker@diehard.n-r-g.com>
Cc:
tech@openbsd.org
Date:
Fri, 17 Jan 2025 15:18:45 +0100

Download raw body.

Thread
  • Mark Kettenis:

    bgpd: drop authors from RFC list

  • > Date: Fri, 17 Jan 2025 13:22:37 +0100
    > From: Claudio Jeker <cjeker@diehard.n-r-g.com>
    > 
    > The list of authors does not add value to the bgpd manual page.
    > So I think it is better to just drop them. With this the list of RFCs
    > becomes shorter and is easier to read.
    
    I know Theo tends to use the word "academic" as an insult, but the
    accepted minimal amount of information in a citation most definitely
    does include author names.
    
    > Index: bgpd.8
    > ===================================================================
    > RCS file: /cvs/src/usr.sbin/bgpd/bgpd.8,v
    > diff -u -p -r1.83 bgpd.8
    > --- bgpd.8	13 Jan 2025 13:50:34 -0000	1.83
    > +++ bgpd.8	17 Jan 2025 12:19:49 -0000
    > @@ -228,378 +228,246 @@ has been started.
    >  .Xr bgplgsh 8
    >  .Sh STANDARDS
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A R. Chandra
    > -.%A P. Traina
    > -.%A "T. Li"
    >  .%D August 1996
    >  .%R RFC 1997
    >  .%T BGP Communities Attribute
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A A. Heffernan
    >  .%D August 1998
    >  .%R RFC 2385
    >  .%T Protection of BGP Sessions via the TCP MD5 Signature Option
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A P. Marques
    > -.%A F. Dupont
    >  .%D March 1999
    >  .%R RFC 2545
    >  .%T Use of BGP-4 Multiprotocol Extensions for IPv6 Inter-Domain Routing
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A E. Chen
    >  .%D September 2000
    >  .%R RFC 2918
    >  .%T Route Refresh Capability for BGP-4
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A G. Huston
    >  .%D April 2004
    >  .%R RFC 3765
    >  .%T NOPEER Community for Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) Route Scope Control
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A Y. Rekhter
    > -.%A "T. Li"
    > -.%A S. Hares
    >  .%D January 2006
    >  .%R RFC 4271
    >  .%T A Border Gateway Protocol 4 (BGP-4)
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A S. Sangli
    > -.%A D. Tappan
    > -.%A Y. Rekhter
    >  .%D February 2006
    >  .%R RFC 4360
    >  .%T BGP Extended Communities Attribute
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A E. Rosen
    > -.%A Y. Rekhter
    >  .%D February 2006
    >  .%R RFC 4364
    >  .%T BGP/MPLS IP Virtual Private Networks (VPNs)
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A T. Bates
    > -.%A E. Chen
    > -.%A R. Chandra
    >  .%D April 2006
    >  .%R RFC 4456
    >  .%T "BGP Route Reflection: An Alternative to Full Mesh Internal BGP (IBGP)"
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A E. Chen
    > -.%A V. Gillet
    >  .%D April 2006
    >  .%R RFC 4486
    >  .%T Subcodes for BGP Cease Notification Message
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A S. Sangli
    > -.%A E. Chen
    > -.%A R. Fernando
    > -.%A J. Scudder
    > -.%A Y. Rekhter
    >  .%D January 2007
    >  .%R RFC 4724
    >  .%T Graceful Restart Mechanism for BGP
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A T. Bates
    > -.%A R. Chandra
    > -.%A D. Katz
    > -.%A Y. Rekhter
    >  .%D January 2007
    >  .%R RFC 4760
    >  .%T Multiprotocol Extensions for BGP-4
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A V. Gill
    > -.%A J. Heasley
    > -.%A D. Meyer
    > -.%A P. Savola
    > -.%A C. Pignataro
    >  .%D October 2007
    >  .%R RFC 5082
    >  .%T The Generalized TTL Security Mechanism (GTSM)
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A J. Scudder
    > -.%A R. Chandra
    >  .%D February 2009
    >  .%R RFC 5492
    >  .%T Capabilities Advertisement with BGP-4
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A Y. Rekhter
    > -.%A S. Sangli
    > -.%A D. Tappan
    >  .%D October 2009
    >  .%R RFC 5668
    >  .%T 4-Octet AS Specific BGP Extended Community
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A E. Chen
    > -.%A J. Yuan
    >  .%D June 2011
    >  .%R RFC 6286
    >  .%T Autonomous-System-Wide Unique BGP Identifier for BGP-4
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A J. Dong
    > -.%A M. Chen
    > -.%A A. Suryanarayana
    >  .%D May 2012
    >  .%R RFC 6608
    >  .%T Subcodes for BGP Finite State Machine Error
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A Q. Vohra
    > -.%A E. Chen
    >  .%D Dec 2012
    >  .%R RFC 6793
    >  .%T BGP Support for Four-Octet Autonomous System (AS) Number Space
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A E. Chen
    > -.%A J. Scudder
    > -.%A P. Mohapatra
    > -.%A K. Patel
    >  .%D August 2015
    >  .%R RFC 7606
    >  .%T Revised Error Handling for BGP UPDATE Messages
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A L. Blunk
    > -.%A M. Karir
    > -.%A C. Labovitz
    >  .%D October 2011
    >  .%R RFC 6396
    >  .%T Multi-Threaded Routing Toolkit (MRT) Routing Information Export Format
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A J. Dong
    > -.%A M. Chen
    > -.%A A. Suryanarayana
    >  .%D May 2012
    >  .%R RFC 6608
    >  .%T Subcodes for BGP Finite State Machine Error
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A K. Patel
    > -.%A E. Chen
    > -.%A B. Venkatachalapathy
    >  .%D July 2014
    >  .%R RFC 7313
    >  .%T Enhanced Route Refresh Capability for BGP-4
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A W. Kumari
    > -.%A R. Bush
    > -.%A H. Schiller
    > -.%A K. Patel
    >  .%D August 2015
    >  .%R RFC 7607
    >  .%T Codification of AS 0 Processing
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A D. Walton
    > -.%A A. Retana
    > -.%A E. Chen
    > -.%A J. Scudder
    >  .%D July 2016
    >  .%R RFC 7911
    >  .%T Advertisement of Multiple Paths in BGP
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A E. Jasinska
    > -.%A N. Hilliard
    > -.%A R. Raszuk
    > -.%A N. Bakker
    >  .%D September 2016
    >  .%R RFC 7947
    >  .%T Internet Exchange BGP Route Server
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A C. Petrie
    > -.%A T. King
    >  .%D May 2017
    >  .%R RFC 8050
    >  .%T Multi-Threaded Routing Toolkit (MRT) Routing Information Export Format with BGP Additional Path Extensions
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A J. Heitz
    > -.%A J. Snijders
    > -.%A K. Patel
    > -.%A I. Bagdonas
    > -.%A N. Hilliard
    >  .%D February 2017
    >  .%R RFC 8092
    >  .%T BGP Large Communities Attribute
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A P. Mohapatra
    > -.%A K. Patel
    > -.%A J. Scudder
    > -.%A D. Ward
    > -.%A R. Bush
    >  .%D March 2017
    >  .%R RFC 8097
    >  .%T BGP Prefix Origin Validation State Extended Community
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A J. Snijders
    > -.%A J. Heitz
    > -.%A J. Scudder
    >  .%D July 2017
    >  .%R RFC 8203
    >  .%T BGP Administrative Shutdown Communication
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A R. Bush
    > -.%A R. Austein
    >  .%D September 2017
    >  .%R RFC 8210
    >  .%T The Resource Public Key Infrastructure (RPKI) to Router Protocol, Version 1
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A J. Mauch
    > -.%A J. Snijders
    > -.%A G. Hankins
    >  .%D July 2017
    >  .%R RFC 8212
    >  .%T Default External BGP (EBGP) Route Propagation Behavior without Policies
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A P. Francois
    > -.%A B. Decraene
    > -.%A C. Pelsser
    > -.%A K. Patel
    > -.%A C. Filsfils
    >  .%D March 2018
    >  .%R RFC 8326
    >  .%T Graceful BGP Session Shutdown
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A K. Patel
    > -.%A R. Fernando
    > -.%A J. Scudder
    > -.%A J. Haas
    >  .%D March 2019
    >  .%R RFC 8538
    >  .%T Notification Message Support for BGP Graceful Restart
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A R. Bush
    > -.%A K. Patel
    > -.%A D. Ward
    >  .%D October 2019
    >  .%R RFC 8654
    >  .%T Extended Message Support for BGP
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A S. Litkowski
    > -.%A S. Agrawal
    > -.%A K. Ananthamurthy
    > -.%A K. Patel
    >  .%D November 2020
    >  .%R RFC 8950
    >  .%T Advertising IPv4 Network Layer Reachability Information (NLRI) with an IPv6 Next Hop
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A C. Loibl
    > -.%A S. Hares
    > -.%A R. Raszuk
    > -.%A D. McPherson
    > -.%A M. Bacher
    >  .%D December 2020
    >  .%R RFC 8955
    >  .%T Dissemination of Flow Specification Rules
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A C. Loibl
    > -.%A R. Raszuk
    > -.%A S. Hares
    >  .%D December 2020
    >  .%R RFC 8956
    >  .%T Dissemination of Flow Specification Rules for IPv6
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A E. Chen
    > -.%A J. Scudder
    >  .%D July 2021
    >  .%R RFC 9072
    >  .%T Extended Optional Parameters Length for BGP OPEN Message
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A A. Azimov
    > -.%A E. Bogomazov
    > -.%A R. Bush
    > -.%A K. Patel
    > -.%A K. Sriram
    >  .%D May 2022
    >  .%R RFC 9234
    >  .%T Route Leak Prevention and Detection Using Roles in UPDATE and OPEN Messages
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A J. Snijders
    > -.%A B. Cartwright-Cox
    > -.%A Y. Qu
    >  .%D November 2024
    >  .%R RFC 9687
    >  .%T Border Gateway Protocol 4 (BGP-4) Send Hold Timer
    >  .Re
    >  .Pp
    >  .Rs
    > -.%A A. Azimov
    > -.%A E. Bogomazov
    > -.%A R. Bush
    > -.%A K. Patel
    > -.%A J. Snijders
    > -.%A K. Sriram
    >  .%D October 2022
    >  .%R draft-ietf-sidrops-aspa-verification
    >  .%T BGP AS_PATH Verification Based on Resource Public Key Infrastructure (RPKI) Autonomous System Provider Authorization (ASPA) Objects
    > 
    > 
    
    
    
  • Mark Kettenis:

    bgpd: drop authors from RFC list